Wednesday, November 4, 2015

Is Reading Entertainment?



Laying in bed the other night, I put down my phone and told my fiance "Okay, I better be productive and read a book."

And he said, "That's not productive; that's entertainment."

And I was totally surprised that he thought that.

And then I was surprised that I was surprised.

Because of course reading is entertainment. Millions of readers all around the world read because they enjoy it. It's a hobby. It's FUN. That's what we believe and tell kids and grownups all day, every day at the library, right?

But the truth is that it sometimes feels like work for librarians.

Sometimes it legitimately is work; if you're serving on a committee, for instance, or if you're prepping for booktalks or if you're reviewing for professional journals. It might be fun work, but it's still work.

But what to do when all reading has started to kinda feel like work? What to do when you're surprised that reading is supposed to be fun?

It's not that I'm not picking up books I enjoy. But somewhere along the way, I've been more focused on hitting (and exceeding) my GoodReads goal. I've been obsessed with my ever-towering mountain of to-be-read books. I've been reading because it feels like an accomplishment to finish a book and mark it down. This is especially true if it's a library book because then I can return it back to the library.

Donalyn Miller had a really great post recently about those times when we take a break from reading or from writing. It got me thinking. Maybe I'm still in Committee Mode after serving on the Newbery Committee last year. I don't remember what a normal reading life is supposed to look like. I read a bunch on my recent Readcation, but I also kind of stressed out about it, which was not very conducive to, y'know, vacationing.

And when I think about other ways I like to relax - watching TV, playing games, taking walks and talking with friends - I never feel like I want to do those activities so I can "be productive" and finish something and mark it down. Not the way I do with reading.

So, I'm going to strive for more balance, and that may mean less reading. But I'm going to strive to be more thoughtful about what I'm reading and why.

Because reading should be entertainment. It should be fun, at least some of the time. Otherwise, what are we doing this librarian thing for?

Do YOU ever feel this way? How do you keep reading fun instead of allowing it to just become part of your job?

Comments (13)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Oh I love this post because it is a thing I think about a lot. And I catch myself thinking "I need to read a book that I don't need to talk about!" That thought forces me to pause and wonder why I had it in the first place.

So I try to let myself enjoy NOT reading. I've been striving to add more non-reading things into my life that I don't need to share or talk about -- making art, writing, watching movies, working out, etc. These are all things I do and enjoy doing and that I let myself enjoy without worrying about not reading this or that or the other thing. I'm also thinking a lot about the value in reading things and...not sharing that I'm reading them. It's hard because it's such a habit, you know? Add the book to Goodreads, write a review, etc. But...why? Maybe it's time to spend time reading a book and THAT'S ALL.

A lot to chew on here :)
1 reply · active 491 weeks ago
Right, it seems so freeing to not have to think about writing a review or who I would recommend a particular book to. And really, during my Newbery year I couldn't use GoodReads and nobody died and I didn't forget every book I read (even the ones I only read once).
I totally hear you, friend. I went straight from reading the longest of Missouri middle grade top titles, to Cybils middle grade round 1 judge, to Newbery. That's been over since January 2014, and I have not returned to my pre-selection committee levels of reading youth literature. About a year ago, I had to have a little talk with myself about how that is FINE. I read occasional titles for reviewing and a handful of work-related requirements, but mostly now I just focus on reading what I want to read. More often than not, recently, that's been adult titles, which is a-okay. I realized that, to do my job, I don't have to have read every single book like I did when I was on committees. Rather, I can read what I'm drawn to, and use my abilities to look to evaluative resources when I need to speak to a title I haven't read. The job is being knowledgeable, resourceful, and conversant in youth lit, not to have read everything. My reading goals are about what I read now, not how much. I feel like I have a much healthier relationship with my reading self since I've sorted that all out.
I feel this. I know I've hit a wall when not only am I reluctant to pick up a book -- any book, for any reason -- but when I do, I don't enjoy it. I DNF'ed a couple of books in the past few weeks that have gotten rave reviews and are likely Newbery contenders, and I just couldn't engage! So, when this happens, yes: I back off. I don't force it. I watch more TV. Or I read grownup comics. Whatever. I do what I need to do a decent job at work, and cut myself some slack in my personal time. My most intensive reading experience was serving as a judge on the Society of Midland Authors Children's Fiction panel last year, and it was so much work I knew immediately I'd never be able (or want) to judge for an even bigger award!
1 reply · active 491 weeks ago
Oh man, I keep thinking about other awards or lists I might want to serve on, and then I think about how MUCH work it is and I feel like I'm not ready... yet. ;)
Oh, Abby, yes, this happens. I'm not even a librarian - just a blogger writing reviews, and this happens to me. The way I generally fight it is by reading things that I have already given myself permission NOT to review (like most books published for adults). This is one of the reasons that I don't review audiobooks on my blog - I listen to a lot of them while I exercise, I purchase most of the ones that I listen to, and I just want those to be for my own entertainment. For my recent readcation I read two adult nonfiction titles. Before blogging, these wouldn't have seemed like "vacation" titles to me, but now they do.
Sometimes you need a break. Good post.
Thank you for this post. This has been something I've been struggling with as a librarian a lot lately. Similar Amy, I was a pretty good reader until I served on a YALSA award committee. After, I found myself suffering from reader's fatigue that I still haven't been able to completely shake. By the time I read all the things I HAVE to read (for work, for my book clubs, and for reviewing) I don't even want to/have time to read anything I actually just WANT to for fun! And I feel this endless twinge of guilt because of it.
I feel this way almost all the time. My books have three distinct categories. The have to read (book clubs, committee work), the should be reading (books to be able to recommend/book talk for schools), and the want to read. They seem to be overlapping less and less lately.
I was on the Newbery waaay back in '95 and found it took me years to get back to reading juvenile/tween fiction for pleasure. Part of it as the intensity of HAVING to read. Part of it was, having read such great books, that when I picked up a "meh" book, I was hypercritical and couldn't enjoy the experience. It helped me to step outside that genre and read kids nonfiction, adult fiction and non-fiction and lots of magazines (I believe I helped maintain a strong circ in the library's periodical collection during a year or two!). It does get better with time!
Hope Baugh's avatar

Hope Baugh · 483 weeks ago

Hi, Abby. I'm late commenting because I'm only just now catching up on your blog (which I love, by the way, and may not have ever told you, or at least not told you enough - thanks for writing it!) but I want to add that this post, in particular, resonated with me, too. For me, the first surprise was when I was working on my MLS degree. Until grad school I had never had so much assigned reading! I wanted to wind down as usual by reading for fun but I couldn't because my eyeballs ached. It was weird, realizing I had to find something else that was as reliable and easy to access as reading for fun. ('Still looking.) More recently, it took me several years to decompress from serving on the Alex committee for four years. That surprised me, too. What helped me was not setting any kind of reading goals or accepting any reading challenges or writing publicly about every book I read BUT continuing to keep my own informal/private/messy reading log and giving myself permission to feel good about whatever my totals were at the end of each year. Also giving myself permission to re-read books that I loved sometimes instead of always driving myself to read something new. 'Sounds like you are finding your own ways to rediscover your own reading joy, too. Happy reading and writing in 2016!

Post a new comment

Comments by